Home » General » Class Action Lawsuit Definition: Rule 23, Key Terms and History

Class Action Lawsuit Definition: Rule 23, Key Terms and History

The class action lawsuit definition, in plain legal terms, is a lawsuit in which a court allows one person or a small group to sue on behalf of a much larger group of people who share the same claim. Everyone in the group is bound by the result. We walk through Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23 clause by clause, compare state rules in California and New York, and define the terms you see in settlement notices. For the bigger picture, read our full guide to how class actions work. This article is general information, not legal advice. A licensed attorney can explain how these rules apply to a specific case.

Quick Facts

ItemDetails
Core ideaRepresentative lawsuit that binds absent group members
Federal ruleFederal Rule of Civil Procedure 23
Four basic testsNumerosity, commonality, typicality, adequacy
Federal jurisdiction lawClass Action Fairness Act of 2005 (CAFA)
California ruleCode of Civil Procedure section 382
New York ruleCPLR Article 9 (sections 901 to 909)
Latest major Rule 23 updateDecember 1, 2018

The Legal Definition in Plain Words

Legal dictionaries such as Black’s Law Dictionary describe a class action as a lawsuit in which the court authorizes a single person or a small group to represent the interests of a larger group. The named plaintiffs stand in for people who are not in court.

Three features set a class action apart from an ordinary lawsuit. First, a judge must approve the group, called “certifying” the class. Second, the outcome binds absent members, whether they win or lose. Third, because absent members cannot speak for themselves, the court must protect them.

Rule 23, Clause by Clause

Rule 23 turns that definition into federal law. It sets the tests a group must pass, the class types allowed and the steps for notice and settlement.

Part of Rule 23What it saysWhat it means
23(a)(1) NumerosityThe class is “so numerous that joinder of all members is impracticable”Too many people to add each one as a plaintiff
23(a)(2) CommonalityThere are common questions of law or factThe same key question runs through every claim
23(a)(3) TypicalityThe representatives’ claims are typical of the classThe lead plaintiffs were hurt the same way as others
23(a)(4) AdequacyRepresentatives will “fairly and adequately protect” the classNo conflicts, and capable lawyers
23(b)(1)Separate suits risk inconsistent rulings or harm absent membersUsed when one ruling must apply to everyone
23(b)(2)Defendant acted on grounds that apply to the whole classMainly for injunctions, such as civil rights cases
23(b)(3)Common questions “predominate” and a class action is “superior”The usual money-damages class; members can opt out
23(c)Court decides certification “at an early practicable time”; notice rulesNotice must explain the case and how to opt out
23(e)Settlement needs court approval as “fair, reasonable, and adequate”The judge checks the deal before it binds anyone
23(f)Appeal petition within 14 days of a certification orderA side can ask an appeals court to review certification
23(g) and 23(h)Appointing class counsel; attorney feesThe court picks the lawyers and sets their pay

Under 23(c)(2)(B), notice in a (b)(3) case must state, in plain language, the nature of the action, the class definition, the claims, the right to hire a lawyer, the right to be excluded, how to opt out and the binding effect of the judgment. You can read the full rule on the federal courts’ rules page.

State Versions: California and New York

States have their own class action rules for cases in state court. Most track Rule 23, but the wording and some limits differ.

California, Code of Civil Procedure section 382. This short statute allows one or more people to sue for everyone’s benefit when the question is “of a common or general interest, of many persons,” or when the parties are so numerous that bringing them all to court is impracticable. California courts often look to Rule 23 for guidance. California’s Consumers Legal Remedies Act has its own class provision, Civil Code section 1781.

New York, CPLR Article 9. Section 901(a) lists five tests: numerosity, common questions that predominate, typicality, adequacy and superiority. Section 901(b) bars class actions that seek a statutory penalty or minimum recovery unless the statute allows it. In Shady Grove v. Allstate (2010), the U.S. Supreme Court held that this limit does not apply in federal court, where Rule 23 controls.

Glossary of Terms in Class Action Notices

Settlement notices use legal shorthand. Here are the terms you will see most.

TermMeaning
Class representativeNamed plaintiff who sues for the whole group
Class counselLawyers the court appoints to represent the class
Putative classProposed class that a court has not yet certified
CertificationCourt order that the case may proceed as a class action
Class definitionDescription of who is in the class, often by date and purchase
Settlement classClass certified only for the purpose of a settlement
SubclassSmaller group inside a class with its own interests
Opt out (exclusion)Leaving the class to keep your right to sue on your own
ObjectorClass member who tells the court why a deal is unfair
ReleaseClaims you give up in exchange for settlement benefits
Common fundSingle pool of money that pays claims, fees and costs
Cy presLeftover money sent to a related charity or cause
Claims administratorNeutral company that sends notice and processes claims
Preliminary approvalCourt finds it will likely approve the deal and allows notice
Fairness hearingHearing where the judge weighs the deal and objections
Final approvalOrder making the settlement binding on the class
Service awardExtra payment to class representatives for their time
MDLMultidistrict litigation: related federal cases grouped before one judge

Class Action vs. Mass Tort vs. MDL vs. Collective Action

These terms are often mixed up. The main differences are whether each person keeps an individual case and whether people must opt in or opt out.

TypeLegal basisHow people joinKey feature
Class actionRule 23 or state ruleAutomatically in; must opt outOne case, one judgment for all
Mass tortOrdinary injury lawEach person files a claimSeparate cases; injuries vary by person
MDL28 U.S.C. section 1407Cases transferred by a judicial panelShared pretrial work; cases stay separate
Collective actionFLSA section 216(b)Must opt in with written consentUsed for federal wage and overtime claims

An MDL is not a class action. The Judicial Panel on Multidistrict Litigation sends similar federal cases to one judge for pretrial steps. Under FLSA section 216(b), no worker becomes a party unless they file written consent with the court.

A Short History of the Class Action Rule

The modern class action grew out of nearly 90 years of rule changes and one major law.

  • 1938: The first Federal Rules of Civil Procedure included Rule 23. It used confusing “true,” “hybrid” and “spurious” class labels.
  • 1966: A rewrite created today’s structure: the four Rule 23(a) tests and the three (b) types, including the opt-out money-damages class.
  • 1998: Rule 23(f) allowed requests for early appeal of certification orders.
  • 2003: New subdivisions (g) and (h) covered class counsel and fees.
  • 2005: CAFA let federal courts hear most class actions with more than 100 members and over $5 million at stake, with only minimal diversity.
  • 2018: Amendments effective December 1, 2018, allowed electronic notice, required a “likely to approve” finding before notice of a settlement, listed approval factors and tightened rules on objector payments.

Conclusion

A class action is a representative lawsuit. A few named plaintiffs sue for many, a court certifies the group, and the result binds everyone who stays in. Rule 23 sets the federal tests, while California’s section 382 and New York’s CPLR Article 9 set state rules. For a real example of a settlement process, see our Shields Health data settlement guide, or browse our latest class action coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the simplest definition of a class action?

It is a lawsuit where one or a few people sue on behalf of a larger group with the same claim, and the result binds the whole group.

What are the four requirements of Rule 23(a)?

Numerosity, commonality, typicality and adequacy of representation. A money-damages class must also show predominance and superiority under Rule 23(b)(3).

What does “putative class” mean?

It is a proposed class that a judge has not yet certified. Until certification, absent members are not formally part of the case.

Is a collective action the same as a class action?

No. In an FLSA collective action, workers must opt in with written consent. In a Rule 23 class action, members are included unless they opt out.

Why does a judge have to approve a class settlement?

Absent members did not negotiate the deal. Rule 23(e) requires the judge to find it fair, reasonable and adequate before it binds them.

Sources

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23, as amended through December 1, 2018
American Bar Association, Litigation Section, on the 2018 Rule 23 changes
Class Action Fairness Act of 2005, Pub. L. 109-2, 28 U.S.C. sections 1332(d), 1453 and 1711 to 1715
28 U.S.C. section 1407, multidistrict litigation
Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. section 216(b)
California Code of Civil Procedure section 382; California Civil Code section 1781
New York Civil Practice Law and Rules, Article 9, sections 901 to 909
Shady Grove Orthopedic Associates v. Allstate Insurance Co., 559 U.S. 393 (2010)
Black’s Law Dictionary, entry for “class action” (paraphrased)