Home » General » Panera Lemonade Lawsuit: Charged Lemonade Cases, Settlements and Status

Panera Lemonade Lawsuit: Charged Lemonade Cases, Settlements and Status

The Panera lemonade lawsuit refers to a group of personal injury and wrongful death cases filed against Panera Bread over its highly caffeinated “Charged Lemonade” drinks. Starting in October 2023, families and customers alleged that the drinks were marketed like ordinary lemonade even though the largest size contained about as much caffeine as the FDA’s daily guideline for healthy adults. The cases drew national attention, and Panera dropped the drink from its menus in May 2024. Panera denied wrongdoing in court filings. According to news reports, all four publicly reported cases were settled, with the last three resolved by July 2025. Terms were not made public. This article covers the claims, the timeline, the current status as of November 2026, and what the cases mean for consumers. It is general information, not legal advice.

Quick FactsDetails
DefendantPanera Bread
ProductCharged Lemonade (launched spring 2022)
Reported caffeineAbout 390 mg in a large 30 oz. cup without ice; 260 mg in a regular, per figures cited in the suits
Publicly reported casesFour: Sarah Katz, Dennis Brown, Lauren Skerritt, Luke Adams
ClaimsWrongful death, personal injury, defective design, failure to warn, misrepresentation
Product statusPhased out of menus in May 2024
Case status (as of November 2026)All four reported cases settled; terms confidential

What Was the Panera Lemonade Lawsuit About?

The lawsuits alleged that Panera sold a high-caffeine drink without clear enough warnings. Plaintiffs said the drink looked and was marketed like a regular fruit lemonade, not an energy drink, and that it was offered at self-serve stations with free refills.

The complaints described the product as “unreasonably dangerous” and defective in design. They also alleged that the drink’s in-store labels compared it to Panera’s dark roast coffee instead of clearly stating its total caffeine. The drinks also contained guarana extract, a plant-based stimulant, according to news reports. Panera denied that its drinks caused the deaths or injuries.

The Four Reported Cases

Four lawsuits were widely reported, and the same Philadelphia-area law firm represented all four plaintiffs, according to NBC News and other outlets. Each case was resolved by settlement.

Sarah Katz (Wrongful Death)

Sarah Katz was a 21-year-old University of Pennsylvania student. Her family’s lawsuit says she drank a Charged Lemonade at a Philadelphia Panera on September 10, 2022, and went into cardiac arrest later that day. She had a heart condition called long QT syndrome and, according to her family, avoided energy drinks. Her parents filed suit in October 2023. The case was later handled in federal court in Philadelphia, where Panera’s motion to dismiss was denied. Panera argued that her death stemmed from a pre-existing condition. The case was set for trial in October 2024 but was settled, and court documents filed in early October 2024 showed it was dismissed.

Dennis Brown (Wrongful Death)

Dennis Brown was a 46-year-old man from Fleming Island, Florida. His family’s lawsuit, filed in Delaware Superior Court in December 2023, alleges that he drank three Charged Lemonades on October 9, 2023, and suffered a fatal cardiac arrest while walking home. The complaint said he had high blood pressure and did not drink energy drinks. Panera said at the time that its investigation showed his death “was not caused by one of the company’s products” and called the suit “without merit.”

Lauren Skerritt (Personal Injury)

Lauren Skerritt, 28, of Rhode Island, and her husband sued in Delaware Superior Court in January 2024. The suit alleges she drank about two and a half Charged Lemonades on April 8, 2023, and developed lasting heart problems, including atrial fibrillation. The complaint said she had no known prior heart issues.

Luke Adams (Personal Injury)

Luke Adams, an 18-year-old from the Pittsburgh area, sued in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania in May 2024, weeks after Panera announced it was phasing out the drink. His complaint alleges he went into cardiac arrest on March 9, 2024, after drinking a large Charged Lemonade and later needed an implanted defibrillator.

How Much Caffeine Was in Charged Lemonade?

The largest Charged Lemonade contained about 390 mg of caffeine when served without ice, according to figures cited in the lawsuits and Panera’s own past nutrition listings. That is close to the 400 mg daily amount the FDA cites for most adults.

DrinkReported Caffeine
Charged Lemonade, large (30 oz., no ice)About 390 mg
Charged Lemonade, large (with ice)About 235–237 mg
Charged Lemonade, regularAbout 260 mg (no ice)
Panera dark roast coffee (20 oz.)About 268 mg
FDA daily guideline for most healthy adults400 mg

Sources differ slightly on the exact figures because Panera listed different numbers for drinks with and without ice. Panera later lowered the listed caffeine to about 155–302 mg, depending on size and flavor, before removing the drink.

Panera’s Response and Discontinuation

Panera added warnings, moved the drink behind the counter in some stores, and then phased it out in May 2024. The company described the change as part of a “menu transformation” and did not tie it to the lawsuits.

After the Katz suit, Panera added enhanced caffeine disclosures in stores and in its app. In March 2026, Panera launched new caffeinated “Energy Refreshers” with far less caffeine, about 28 to 44 mg depending on cup size, along with a warning for children, caffeine-sensitive people, and pregnant or nursing women.

Timeline of the Panera Lemonade Lawsuit

DateEvent
Spring 2022Panera introduces Charged Lemonade
September 10, 2022Sarah Katz dies after drinking the beverage, per her family’s lawsuit
April 8, 2023Lauren Skerritt drinks the beverage, per her lawsuit
October 9, 2023Dennis Brown dies, per his family’s lawsuit
October 2023Katz family files wrongful death suit; Panera adds caffeine disclosures
December 2023Brown family files suit in Delaware Superior Court
January 2024Skerritt suit filed in Delaware Superior Court
March 9, 2024Luke Adams suffers cardiac arrest, per his lawsuit
May 2024Panera confirms it is phasing out Charged Lemonade
May 2024Adams suit filed in federal court in Pennsylvania
October 2024Katz case settled and dismissed ahead of trial
July 2025Brown, Skerritt, and Adams cases dismissed with prejudice after settlement
March 2026Panera launches lower-caffeine Energy Refreshers

Settlements and Current Status

As of November 2026, every publicly reported Charged Lemonade lawsuit has been settled. The amounts and terms were not disclosed, and Panera did not admit liability.

In July 2025, NBC News reported, citing court records, that the remaining three cases were dismissed with prejudice, meaning they cannot be refiled. The plaintiffs’ lawyer confirmed that “the matters have all been resolved.” Panera acknowledged the settlements but did not comment further. We found no new Charged Lemonade lawsuits reported by major news outlets after that date.

Was There a Class Action?

We could not find any certified or widely reported class action over Charged Lemonade labeling. The publicly reported cases were individual injury and death claims, not group cases. To learn how group cases differ, see our guide on what a class action lawsuit is.

What It Means for Consumers

The cases are a reminder to check caffeine content, especially in restaurant drinks that do not look like energy drinks. The FDA says 400 mg a day is an amount not generally linked to negative effects for most healthy adults, but sensitivity varies from person to person.

According to the FDA’s consumer guidance on caffeine, people who are pregnant, trying to become pregnant, or breastfeeding should talk with a health care provider about limits, and experts advise against energy drinks for children and teens. People with heart conditions should ask their doctor about caffeine. Under state law, families can sometimes bring a wrongful death claim when they believe a product caused a death. A licensed attorney can explain whether such a claim may apply in a specific case. For similar restaurant cases, see our coverage of the Arby’s lawsuit.

Conclusion

The Panera lemonade lawsuit involved four reported cases over Charged Lemonade, including two wrongful death claims. Panera denied the allegations, removed the drink in May 2024, and settled all four cases by July 2025 on undisclosed terms. The cases are closed, but they changed how Panera labels and sells caffeinated drinks. For more consumer cases, browse our class action coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the Panera lemonade lawsuit still active?

No. As of November 2026, all four publicly reported cases have been settled and dismissed, according to news reports.

How much did Panera pay in the settlements?

The amounts were not made public. Neither side disclosed the terms.

Can I join the Panera lemonade lawsuit?

No. These were individual cases, not a class action, and they are closed. A licensed attorney can review whether any separate claim is possible.

Is Panera Charged Lemonade still sold?

No. Panera phased it out in May 2024. Its newer Energy Refreshers contain much less caffeine.

Did Panera admit fault?

No. Panera denied liability in its court filings and did not admit wrongdoing in the settlements, based on public reports.

Sources

NBC News reporting on the settlements (October 2024 and July 2025), as cited by Yahoo News and Nation’s Restaurant News; Global News (October 2024); The Spokesman-Review/Associated Press (October 8, 2024); CBS News (December 2023); The Boston Globe (January 19, 2024); TribLive (2024); TODAY timeline of the lawsuits (2024); PhillyVoice (May 7, 2024); WTAP/Gray News (March 14, 2026); U.S. Food and Drug Administration, “Spilling the Beans: How Much Caffeine Is Too Much?”; Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, “Wrongful Death.”